GRE Analytical Writing Examples: Examining Unstated Assumptions

The argument that luxury goods are nonessential and their market will be the first to decrease in a present economic climate, with luxury retailers refocusing on lower-priced markets, is based on several unstated assumptions. This essay will examine these assumptions, exploring how they influence the argument's validity and potential implications if they prove unwarranted.

Firstly, the assumption that luxury goods are inherently nonessential implies that their value lies solely in their aesthetic appeal or social status. However, luxury brands often invest heavily in research and development to create high-quality products with unique features and craftsmanship. These factors may justify higher prices and justify consumer willingness to spend on them despite economic downturns.

Secondly, the argument relies on the assumption that a decline in the average household's spending power will directly affect luxury goods market share without considering alternative scenarios. For instance, consumers might opt for lower-priced alternatives within the same product category or switch to online shopping platforms with better deals. This could lead to new competitors emerging and potentially maintaining sales levels.

Thirdly, the assumption that luxury retailers should automatically refocus on lower-priced markets neglects their existing brand reputation, customer loyalty, and marketing strategies. Luxury brands may choose to maintain their premium image by targeting a niche market segment or exploring alternative revenue streams, such as high-end services or experiences.

Fourthly, the argument assumes that economic downturns will uniformly affect all consumer goods categories without considering differences in product life cycles, industry trends, or regional variations. For example, some luxury products, like watches or jewelry, may have longer lifespans and be less susceptible to economic fluctuations.

Lastly, the assumption that luxury retailers should prioritize lower-priced markets over their existing customer base ignores the potential long-term damage to brand reputation and loyalty. Focusing solely on price might lead to a loss of high-end clientele and undermine the very foundation of their business model.

In conclusion, while the argument presents some logical points, it relies heavily on unstated assumptions that warrant closer examination. To strengthen its validity, the argument should consider alternative scenarios, industry trends, and regional variations. Additionally, luxury retailers might choose to maintain their premium image by targeting niche markets or exploring new revenue streams. By acknowledging these complexities, a more convincing case can be made for refocusing on lower-priced markets.

Gre analytical writing examples